A comparison of two debriefing methods on clinical reasoning outcomes, learner satisfaction with debriefing and reflection, clinical learning and clinical reasoning, and psychological safety of nurse orientees in simulation-based education
Lori A. Persico, PhD, CHSE, RN
- Sigma Affiliation
Visits vs Downloads
Visitors - World Map
Top Visiting Countries
Top Visiting Cities
Visits (last 6 months)
Downloads (last 6 months)
Popular Works for Persico, Lori A. by View
Popular Works for Persico, Lori A. by Download
Simulation-based education is a teaching method used successfully in military, aviation, and medical education; however, the evidence rarely indicates how debriefing affects the learners’ experiences. Debriefing is an essential component of simulation-based education that fosters conceptual learning, critical thinking, and clinical reasoning. The purpose of this study was to compare the effects of two different debriefing methods on nurses’ perceptions of psychological safety, satisfaction with development of clinical reasoning skills, and satisfaction with learning. In this quasi-experimental, posttest study the researcher explored the effect of each debriefing method. Using the 18-item Satisfaction with Simulation Experience Scale developed by Levett-Jones et al. (2011), the researcher measured learners’ satisfaction with the simulation learning experience. The researcher developed a visual analog scale to measure the learner’s perceived psychological safety. During the simulation learning experience part of an orientation, the researcher used two debriefing methods using the 3D Model of Debriefing: (1) Defusing, Discovering and Deepening (3D-DDD) and (2) the DEBRIEF method. The literature clearly articulates how these models are distinct in how debriefing is executed in the simulation experience. The “debriefers” received appropriate training on the models and were then verified by the investigator for treatment fidelity. After each debrief method, the researcher measured the participants’ experiences including psychological safety and satisfaction, as well as clinical reasoning skills. The researcher divided study participants into two groups and administered one of the two debriefing models. By alternating debrief methods, the researcher ensured that all groups in each month were debriefed using the same method. Both methods resulted in psychological safety and satisfaction. There were no statistically significant differences in either debrief method for the SSES, VAS, and case study scores. The analysis did not identify anymeaningful relationships between a learner’s characteristics and satisfaction in debriefing and reflection, self-reported clinical reasoning, and clinical learning. The literature recognizes debriefing as a vital teaching strategy, but there remains minimal research on how to debrief, which methods are effective at achieving learning outcomes, and which are best at fulfilling an individual’s psychological safety.
This dissertation has also been disseminated through the ProQuest Dissertations and Theses database. Dissertation/thesis number: 10634025; ProQuest document ID: 1970496271. The author still retains copyright.
This item has not gone through this repository's peer-review process, but has been accepted by the indicated university or college in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the specified degree.
|Review Type||None: Degree-based Submission|
|Evidence Level||Quasi-Experimental Study, Other|
|Research Approach||Posttest Study|
All rights reserved by the author(s) and/or publisher(s) listed in this item record unless relinquished in whole or part by a rights notation or a Creative Commons License present in this item record.
All permission requests should be directed accordingly and not to the Sigma Repository.
All submitting authors or publishers have affirmed that when using material in their work where they do not own copyright, they have obtained permission of the copyright holder prior to submission and the rights holder has been acknowledged as necessary.
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subjects.
Embedding simulation-based learning in a capstone undergraduate nursing subject to develop clinical reasoning skills Nightingale, Karen Elizabeth (2016-03-17)Session presented on Thursday, July 23, 2015: Reflective learning and clinical reasoning skills are highly valued and even deemed essential in healthcare professions where constantly changing situations require effective ...
The Psychological Safety Assessment Survey in simulation-based prelicensure nursing education: Is the model supported? Daniels, Amy L.; Breman, Rachel BlanksteinPsychological Safety (PS), deemed essential for quality simulation-based nursing education, remains unmeasured. This presentation disseminates findings of a narrative literature review of nursing education literature ...
Comparing the effects of two debriefing frameworks; Promoting excellence and reflective learning in simulation (PEARLS) framework and structured and supported debriefing model (GAS) framework Prendergast, Krista M.Essential learning occurs during the debriefing phase of simulation-based learning experiences. Despite this knowledge, evidence regarding the most effective debriefing method is insufficient. The primary purpose of this ...
The effectiveness of a nursing simulation-based learning program on students' competence and learning satisfaction Cheng, Hsiu-Rong; Tseng, Ying-Fen; Tu, Yu-Ching; Li, Yueh-PingCompared with the control group, the experimental group had significant higher scores of adult nursing skill test and fundamental nursing skill test, learning satisfaction, and higher passing rate of Professional and ...
Executive summary of CRiticAL – Clinical Reasoning and simulation -The passive observer becomes Active Learner Tutticci, Naomi F.; Theobald, Karen; Ramsbotham, Joanne; Johnston, Sandra E.This report details the findings from a main study which used a two group non-equivalent control group design to examine the application of clinical reasoning by nursing students who observed a high fidelity simulation to ...