The effect of deliberate practice combined with high-fidelity simulation scenarios on psychomotor skill competency and retention in prelicensure nursing education: A mixed methods pilot study
Cynthia E. Johnson, PhD, RN
- Sigma Affiliation
Visits vs Downloads
Visitors - World Map
Top Visiting Countries
Top Visiting Cities
Visits (last 6 months)
Downloads (last 6 months)
Popular Works for Johnson, Cynthia by View
Popular Works for Johnson, Cynthia by Download
Graduating students who are proficient in the representative skills of nursing are vital for providing safe, quality patient care. The purpose of this pilot mixed method study was to examine the combined effect of deliberate skill practice prior to high-fidelity simulation (HFS) sessions and skill practice during HFS scenarios of the urinary catheter insertion skill on psychomotor skill competency and retention in prelicensure nursing students. The study was based on Ericsson’s framework of deliberate practice for skill acquisition and expert performance. Using a randomized controlled experimental design, a convenience sample of 28 senior level prelicensure nursing students (mean age 21.82, SD 2.9, 96% Caucasian) were randomized into one o f three groups. Each group participated in four, five-hour HFS scenario sessions with three different teaching methodologies. The control group (Group A) participated in the traditional HFS education method and no skill practice occurred. The second group (Group B) participated in deliberate practice of a different previously learned skill prior to each session. Then Group B participated in HFS scenarios in which the urinary catheter insertion skill was performed. Group C participated in deliberate practice of the urinary catheter insertion skill prior to each HFS session and then performed the urinary catheter insertion skill during each HFS scenario. Quantitative data collection consisted of a urinary catheter insertion pre-test skill competency assessment, a post-test skill competency assessment, and a post-test skill retention assessment. Qualitative data collection with seven students occurred after the completion of the quantitative strand with face-to-face semi-structured interviews Results revealed no statistically significant difference in the groups on skill competency. However, the participants in the deliberate practice with HFS group (Group C) demonstrated an improvement in the overall total mean scores on urinary catheter insertion assessment and a medium eta effect size was found. Thus, the intervention of combining deliberate skill practice prior to HFS along with skill practice during HFS had a direct effect on the dependent variable (urinary catheter insertion competency assessment). In the qualitative strand, three themes were identified including Not the Best Place for Learning a Skill, Learning Skills with Peers, and Performing Skills for a Grade. The qualitative data supported the quantitative findings and resulted in the discovery of the value of consistent peer to peer deliberate urinary catheter insertion practice prior to HFS scenario skill practice. This study provides preliminary data on the combination of deliberate peer to peer practice prior to FIFS scenario skill practice may improve student urinary catheter insertion skill acquisition and retention. Because of the pilot nature of the study, the findings need to be confirmed in a larger clinical trial.
This dissertation has also been disseminated through the ProQuest Dissertations and Theses database. Dissertation/thesis number: 10302144; ProQuest document ID: 1857513490. The author still retains copyright.
This item has not gone through this repository's peer-review process, but has been accepted by the indicated university or college in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the specified degree.
|Review Type||None: Degree-based Submission|
|Evidence Level||Randomized Controlled Trial|
|Research Approach||Pilot/Exploratory Study|
High Fidelity Simulation;
Skill Competency and Retention
|CINAHL Subject(s)||Students, Nursing;
All rights reserved by the author(s) and/or publisher(s) listed in this item record unless relinquished in whole or part by a rights notation or a Creative Commons License present in this item record.
All permission requests should be directed accordingly and not to the Sigma Repository.
All submitting authors or publishers have affirmed that when using material in their work where they do not own copyright, they have obtained permission of the copyright holder prior to submission and the rights holder has been acknowledged as necessary.
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subjects.
The effect of high-fidelity simulation and traditional didactic lecture on first semester junior baccalaureate nursing students' knowledge acquisition, and self-confidence using the Solomon-Four Group research design Williams, TrudyNurse educators are challenged with preparing nurses to practice in complex Health care settings. Nursing graduates often feel unprepared to meet the performance expectations placed on them by the Health care industry, ...
Assessment of nursing students’ knowledge acquisition and knowledge retention regarding blood administration using high-fidelity simulation Hooper, Barbara L.; Carlson, Nancy; Ware, KatelynThe purpose of this study was to measure knowledge acquisition and retention among nursing students participating in a blood administration simulation. Knowledge acquisition was measured with a pre-test prior to the ...
The effect of high-fidelity simulation (HFS) on first semester baccalaureate nursing students' knowledge acquisition/self-confidence Williams, TrudyThis presentation highlights the role of a HFS-focused respiratory physical assessment intervention in improving self-confidence and knowledge in undergraduate nursing students. The learner will be able discuss the benefits ...
Central intravenous skills using high-fidelity simulation versus traditional methodologies among undergraduate nursing student Hartman, Kristie O.Nurse educators have been faced with a paradigm shift in meeting the needs of a technologically advanced generation. Healthcare demands and high faculty to student ratios require methodologies that facilitate clinical ...
Gilson, Stacy A.Quality care, patient safety and population health are required competencies for baccalaureate nursing program education. Faculty designed a mass casualty incident simulation for senior baccalaureate nursing students ...